
|
|
![[ Bankers Trust Research logo]](images/btlogo.gif)
| Emerging Markets Research Database |
Lite-On Electronics: Dependable Power in a New Light - AW 4/99
Bankers Trust Research/BT Alex. Brown Research
Lloyd Ong
April 01, 1999
BT Alex. Brown
ASIA WINDOW (April 1999)
Taiwan - Convertibles
LITE-ON ELECTRONICS
DEPENDABLE POWER IN A NEW LIGHT
BUY 0.5% CB due '04
Lloyd Ong (852) 2533-8116
Lloyd.ong@bankerstrust.com
Investment Summary
We initiate coverage of Lite-On Electronics (Lite-On) with a
BUY on the 0.5% CB due '04. The CB is currently trading at a
price of 98 and a YTP of 10.7% (T+573 bps).
We have a Buy recommendation on the CB because we think an
expected return of 10.7% offers attractive value relative to
the company's strong credit fundamentals. For 1998, we
estimated the debt-to-EBITDA ratio at 2.6 times and EBITDA-
to-interest ratio at 4.7 times. With sales and margins
having bottomed out at the end of last year, we think
earnings prospects for Lite-On should improve going forward.
As the company continues to shift and expand its production
in China, it can reap substantial margin benefit. Margin on
its China products is estimated to be 10% higher than its
operation in Taiwan.
Conversely, we see limited value in the equity feature of
the CB due to the high premium of 74.4%. According to our
conversion return calculation, we estimate the underlying
share would need to achieve a breakeven price of NT$132.5 in
order for the equity option to yield an equivalent return to
the YTP of 10.7% on the put date. With Lite-On's shares
trading at NT$57.5, the share price would therefore have to
appreciate by an annual rate of 29% during the life of the
CB. As such, we think it would be a hard task for the shares
to perform to such a high valuation level even with our
higher earnings forecasts for the company. On a P/E
valuation basis, we believe the company should trade between
a range of 18-20 times in the medium term.
Investment Considerations
Positives
- Strong financial position. In our view, Lite-On's
financial position is strong. Its low costs, cash
generative switching power supplies (SPS) and opto-
electronics businesses have allowed the company to
maintain a consistently low leverage, with net debt
estimated at 0.16 times in 1998. The debt-to-EBITDA ratio
is estimated at 2.6 times in 1998 and should improve to
2.0 times in 1999. Despite higher interest costs from
increased short-term bank borrowings, EBITDA-to interest
ratio is likely to improve to 5.3 times in 1999, up from
4.7 times in 1998.
- A major player in SPS and opto-electronics industries. As
the world's 10th largest producer of switching power
supplies (SPS) and opto-electronics products, we believe
Lite-On is poised to rise up the ranks as new capacities
are rapidly coming on-line from its facilities in Dongguan
and Tianjin, China. SPS and opto-electronics accounted for
65% and 35% of total revenue for Lite-On in 1998.
- Top-tier customer base. Lite-On has a solid customer list,
including market leaders in the PC, computer peripherals
and office automation sectors such as Compaq, IBM, Dell,
Packard Bell-NEC, Twinhead, I-Omega and Canon. We estimate
the top five customers accounted for more than 85% of its
total sales in the power conversion division in 1998. In
the opto division, the company has strong business
relationships with such major telecommunication players as
Motorola, Samsung, Philips, Thomson and Microsoft, which
together accounted for 30% of total opto sales in 1998.
The OEM markets are significant as they typically drive
component demand.
- Global manufacturing and distribution capabilities.
Besides its onshore production facilities, Lite-On has
established key manufacturing plants in Thailand (opto
products); Malaysia (SPS); UK (SPS); Dongguan (SPS); and
Tianjin (Opto). Its extensive overseas presence has given
the company's competitive advantage through lower cost
structure, which is critical in this low margin and price
sensitive industry. In addition, its global operation has
enhanced time-to-market and services for its overseas OEM
customers.
- Diversified customer base across various industries. In
the highly competitive SPS and opto businesses, Lite-On
serves a diverse section of core customers in the
computer, telecommunication and office automation markets.
The company also provides a wide array of products, thus
reducing the risk of product obsolescence. Its revenue and
earnings stream is thus more stable than its semiconductor
counterparts.
- Strong demand in sub-US$1,000 PCs to drive SPS growth.
Although increased demand for low-end PCs will pressure
SPS' pricing and margins, we believe the impact will be
more than offset by stronger volume growth, thus
benefiting major original design manufacturers (ODM) like
Lite-On. In our view, the company is well positioned to
gain further market share as it continues to ramp up
capacity in China. We expect revenue contribution from its
mainland operations to hit 60% by 2000, up from 40% last
year.
Negatives
- Pricing pressure. Like all component suppliers in the PC
industry, Lite-On suffered from persistent pricing
pressure in 1998. The decline in average selling price
(ASP), especially in the SPS business, was attributed to
overcapacity caused by slower than expected PC growth in
the last quarter of 1998. We estimate the ASP of power
supplies has declined by 20% in 1998. Corresponding,
Lite-On's operating margin contracted to 7.7% in 1998,
down from 12% in 1997. We expect further pricing pressure
in the near term as consolidation takes hold on the power
supply industry.
- Low financial transparency. Lite-On Group reports detailed
consolidated financials only once a year. On a quarterly
basis, earnings from its unlisted overseas operations are
reported under the company's unconsolidated investment
income line. With increasing contributions from its
mainland operations - Lite-On (Tianjin) and Dongguan Lite
Power Plant, analyzing the company's results are difficult
and fraught with potential earnings surprises going
forward. For 1998, we estimate investment income accounted
for a high 40% of unconsolidated net profit.
- Strong competition. With the desktop and notebook
businesses as its main markets, Lite-On faces significant
direct competition, especially from Astec BSR (Hong Kong)
and Delta Electronics (Taiwan), the world's 2nd and 4th
largest producers of SPS. These companies occupy similar
niches in the market and are financially much stronger,
supplying more than 80% of their output to PC OEMs. While
competition is endemic to the PC component business, we
are optimistic that Lite-On, with its strong R&D,
competitive cost structure and strong customer
relationships, will continue to strengthen its market
position in both the SPS and opto-electronics businesses.
Background
Lite-On Electronics is among the world top ten suppliers of
opto-electronics devices and switching power supplies. It
was founded in 1975 and was the first electronics company to
list on the Taiwan Stock Exchange. The company is part of
the Lite-On Group, a diversified electronics conglomerate in
Taiwan that also includes publicly listed companies such as
Lite-On Technology, Silitek Corp. and Dyna Image Corp.
Although Raymond Soong and family only have a direct equity
holding of 4% in the company, their actual ownership stake
is believed to be much higher through the complex cross
shareholding structure within the group's wholly-owned
oversea subsidiaries and sister companies.
In the opto-electronics division, the company has developed
a wide range of infra-red LED products that include
photodiodes, lamps, photocouplers, receivers and clock
display. Major competitors are mainly small divisions of
leading electronics players like Sharp, Hewlett-Packard and
Sony. In the power conversion division, the company provides
a full range of SPS for application in the PC,
telecommunication and office automation devices.
Consolidation is the theme in the power supply industry
More than a dozen acquisitions occurred in the past year and
we think the trend is likely to intensify in the coming
years. As pressure on pricing escalates, especially from
large OEM customers, consolidation and strategic alliances
are likely to be forged between power supply companies to
achieve the critical economies of scale and larger customer
base required to survive in this fiercely contested
industry. Major players will have the advantage of high-
volume component purchasing to reduce the cost of power
supplies where raw materials typically take up about 75% of
total production cost. The most notable acquisitions that
have occurred include Computer Products' acquisition of
Zytec in the US; Astec's purchase of Northern Telecom's
Advanced Power Systems; Siebe Power Controls (parent of
Lambda Electronics) takeover of Electronic Measurement; and
Celestica Power Systems' acquisition of Ascent Power
Technologies. As the industry still has more than 300
companies globally, of which more than 100 are in Taiwan,
there will be plenty of acquisition opportunities in the
market, in our view. Many of the smaller and weaker players
will likely be acquired or go under in coming years if
prices remain soft.
In Asia, major power supply makers however have been ramping
up capacities at a furious pace despite falling prices. For
1998 and beyond, we expect Taiwan to maintain its position
as the world's largest supplier of SPS with an estimated
market share of more than 60%. The two major suppliers in
the country, Lite-On and Delta Electronics, in our opinion,
are well positioned to capitalize on the consolidation trend
to strengthen its market share further in view of their
healthy financial positions, low cost structures, economies
of scale, and strong distribution and procurement
capabilities.
Conversion Return Scenario
Our conversion return scenario table illustrates that the
yield obtain from CB conversion is highly sensitivity to the
time required in achieving targeted share prices. Based on
the yield (bold figures) calculated in the table, investors
would gain an attractive return over the YTP, if the
underlying share reaches the targeted prices at the
stipulated dates.
Based on our return scenario, we have calculated that the
breakeven share price on the put date for Lite-On's CB is
NT$132.5. At this price, the securities will earn a return
equivalent to the YTP of 10.7%. With a current share price
at NT$57.5, this means that the equity would have to
appreciate by an average of 29% per annum until the put date
(3.25 years) just to breakeven on the YTP. If the share
price trades above the breakeven price on put date, CB
holders would be better off converting the securities by
earning the additional yield over the YTP of 10.7%, as shown
in shaded bold. Conversely, if the underlying share price
trades below the breakeven price, then our calculations
indicate that CB holders should put the bonds.
Financial Analysis
Lite-On's financial position is strong. Its low-cost, cash
generative SPS and opto-electronics businesses have allowed
the company to maintain a low leverage, with net debt
estimated at 0.16 times in 1998. The debt-to-EBITDA ratio is
estimated at 2.6 times in 1998 and should improve to 2.0
times in 1999. Due to higher interest expense incurred
resulting from higher bank borrowings in 1998, EBITDA-to-
gross interest expense ratio is expected to fall from 10.2
times in 1997 to 4.7 times in 1998, which is still high in
view of the lower business volatility. We expect EBITDA to
strengthen in the next two years as the company ramped up
its production in the mainland to cut costs and boost
operating margin. We estimate the interest coverage ratio
could improve to 6.3 times and 6.6 times in 1999 and 2000,
respectively.
Despite suffering from a decline in revenue and earnings in
1998 on a consolidated basis, the credit fundamentals of
Lite-On remain attractive. After sales growth peaked in the
3rd quarter of last year, the company experienced continuous
price pressure for its SPS products and LED (light emitting
diode) chips. As a result, the company was unable to
maintain its growth momentum into the 4th quarter, which led
to a 14.8% q-o-q sequential decline in revenue and an
overall negative growth of 11.4% at group level. We estimate
operating margin to fall from 12.0% in 1997 to 7.7% in 1998
while the pre-tax margin to contract from 14.0% to 12.5% due
mainly to foreign exchange gain. Although we expect pricing
pressure to continue in the medium term, we think further
compression in its operating margin is unlikely as the
company continues to ramp up production capacity from its
efficient mainland plants and increase its value-added
production to help reduce operating costs. We estimate Lite-
On's mainland plants' gross margin to be at least 10% higher
than its counterpart in Taiwan.
Management is expected to spend NT$1.0 billion in 1999,
mostly for capacity expansion in mainland plants and
improvements to other plants. Funding is expected to come
from internal reserves for now. Even if the company decides
to use debt to fund the expansion, we do not anticipate
substantial incremental in leverage in 1999, which is
estimated at 0.46 times
Earnings Outlook
After a sluggish year of sales performance attributed to
continuous price pressure in 1998, we believe Lite-On will
regain its earnings growth momentum over the next few years
in line with improving fundamentals of the PC markets and
stronger demand in the communications and consumer
electronics products. We anticipate the company will benefit
strongly from an increase in foreign orders, particularly in
the ODM segment and the expanding mainland market, where it
has been investing heavily in the last two years. The
company expects revenue from its mainland operations to
increase from 40% in 1998 to more than 60% by 2000. We
estimate sales to grow at 18% and 20% in 1999 and 2000,
respectively.
With increased capacity and the production of higher value-
added products, Lite-On should be able to boost revenue and
earnings in the next few years. Growth in the opto-
electronics segment should be fueled by solid demand in the
communications and digital consumer electronics markets
while the SPS business will continue to be driven by
intrinsic growth in PC and PC server markets.
Recommendation
Being a major player in the SPS and opto-electronics
industry, we believe Lite-On is well positioned to gain
further market share as the industry undergoes consolidation
in the near future. Even though the underlying equity
feature has very little value, in our view, we recommend a
BUY on the 0.5% CB due '04 in view of the attractive YTP of
10.7% relative to the company's sound financial position,
strong business fundamentals and improving earnings outlook.
Additional information available upon request.
Although information herein has been obtained from sources
believed to be reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy,
completeness or fairness. Opinions and estimates may be
changed or withdrawn without notice. This report is not
intended as an offer or solicitation, or as the basis for
any contract, for the purchase or sale of any security, loan
or other instrument. We or our affiliates or persons
associated with us or such affiliates ("Associated Persons")
may: maintain a long or short position in securities, loans
or other instruments referred to herein or in other
securities, loans or instruments of issuers named herein, or
in related derivatives; purchase or sell, make a market in,
or engage in other transactions involving such securities,
loans or instruments of such issuers; and/or provide
investment banking, credit, or other services to any issuer
named herein. The past performance of securities, loans or
other instruments does not guarantee or predict future
performance. This report may not be reproduced or
circulated without our written authority and must not be
distributed to private customers in the U.K. Bankers Trust
International ("BTI") or its Associated Persons may act upon
or use material in this report prior to publication.
Transaction strategies described in this document are merely
concepts of investment strategies that might be pursued
given a particular view of one or more markets. The
strategies decribed in this document may not be appropriate
for all investors as it is not possible to take into account
individual circumstances. Investors should obtain
individual financial advice before acting on recommendations
in this document.
This report has been prepared by employees of Bankers Trust
Company, Hong Kong. This report has been distributed in the
jurisdictions listed below by the Bankers Trust affiliates
named below. This report has been distributed in all other
jurisdictions by Bankers Trust International PLC, regulated
by SFA and approved by BTI. BT Alex. Brown Incorporated
accepts responsibility for this report in the United States,
and persons in the United States wishing to effect any
transactions should contact BT Alex. Brown Incorporated.
Copyright 1999 Bankers Trust Corporation. All rights
reserved.
This report has been distributed in Australia by Bankers
Trust Australia Limited (ACN 003 017 221). Bankers Trust
Australia Limited is a licensed securities dealer in
Australia. For further information in Australia contact;
Paul Bide (612) 9259 3652.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BT Alex. Brown Incorporated
One Bankers Trust Plaza
New York, NY 10006
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BT Alex. Brown Incorporated
One South Street
Baltimore, MD 21202
UNITED KINGDOM
BT Alex. Brown International
(a division of Bankers Trust Int'l PLC, Regulated by SFA)
135 Bishopsgate
London EC2M 3XT
UNITED KINGDOM
BT Alex. Brown International
(a division of Bankers Trust Int'l PLC, Regulated by SFA)
Kintore House, 74-77 Queens Street
Edinburgh EH2 4NS
HONG KONG
Bankers Trust Company
36th Floor, Two Pacific Place
88 Queensway
Hong Kong
SINGAPORE
Bankers Trust Company
5 Temasek Blvd #08-00
Suntec City Tower
Singapore 038985
BT Brokerage & Associates PTE Ltd
20 Collyer Quay #19-00
Tung Center
Singapore 049319
AUSTRALIA
Bankers Trust Australia Limited
Level 15, The Chifley Tower
2 Chifley Square
Sydney
N.S.W. 2000 Australia
KOREA
Bankers Trust International PLC
Hanwha Building, 12th Floor
111-5 Sokong-dong, Chung-ku
Seoul, Korea 100-070
THIS REPORT MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED IN MALAYSIA AND THAILAND
| DISCLAIMER: The information and opinions contained herein do not necessarily express the opinions of BradyNet, Inc. This report has been prepared solely for informational purposes and is not a solicitation of any transaction in the securities with which it deals or an offer to enter into any such transaction. Prices and/or other information in this report are subject to change without prior notice. |
Copyright © 1998 BradyNet, Inc. |

Please read our disclaimer.
Home Page |
BradyNet Pro |
Search |
CyberExchange
General Correspondence: bradynet@bradynet.com
Questions/Problems? support@bradynet.com
This site copyright © 1995-2000 BradyNet.com
Forfaiting |
Closing Prices |
Live Prices |
New Issues |
Ratings
BradyNet Tour |
BradyNet FORUMs |
BradyNet Email Directory |
Index (Site Map)
Analysis & Research |
BradyNet Center |
News |
Jobs